FOR BUSH BROTHERS, THE DRUG WAR HITS HOME

Late-night comedians have the drug hungers of Noelle Bush, daughter of
Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and niece of the nation's president, George W. Bush,
to kick around some more. But let's get serious for a moment.

Noelle, 25, needs help. She has, in the parlance of these times, "issues."
She was found with crack cocaine in her shoe on Sept. 9 at a drug treatment
center in Orlando where she was in a court-ordered drug rehabilitation
program. You know somebody's got a S-E-R-I-O-U-S drug problem when they get
caught with illicit drugs while in rehab.

But we already knew Noelle's problem was serious when she spent three days
in jail back in July for contempt of court after she was found with
prescription pills that did not belong to her. They belonged to a treatment
center worker, according to news reports, and had been taken from a cabinet.

Noelle Bush was assigned to the treatment facility back in January after
she was arrested on charges of trying to obtain Xanax, an anti-anxiety
drug, with a fraudulent prescription at a Tallahassee pharmacy
drive-through window.

Her father, facing reporters after Noelle's latest incident, showed the
proper attitude for a parent in such circumstances, which is compassion.
"This is a private issue as it relates to my daughter and myself and my
wife," he said. "The road to recovery is a rocky one for a lot of people
that have this kind of problem." The governor's pun ("rock" is common
street slang for crack cocaine) was unintended, yet ironically appropriate.
The road to recovery is uphill and slippery, loaded with backslides for
many of those who take it.

The tragedy is that there are thousands of other Noelles out there whose
fathers and families are not well-off or well-connected and they don't have
the opportunity to stay in nice treatment centers.

Instead, they spend their nights in jail.

Gov. Bush and his wife wisely re-quested that their daughter be referred to
one of the best drug treatment centers in their state. But the governor has
reduced state funding for drug treatment programs which, like those in
every other state, have waiting lists of drug abusers seeking help.

And he says he opposes a treatment-instead-of-incarceration initiative that
proponents expect to put on the Florida ballot in 2004.

A similar reform measure passed in California in 2000, new ones will appear
on this November's ballot in Ohio and the District of Columbia, and similar
measures are underway in other states, either by ballot initiative or
referendum.

In California, for example, drug abusers have to be sent to treatment after
their first two arrests, if they are not involved in other criminal
activity. Those who fail while in treatment, as Noelle did, must be offered
an alternative form of treatment, not jail.

California's measure also doubled state funding for treatment to reduce the
waiting lists. Ohio's measure calls for a similar increase in drug
treatment funding.

As Ethan Nadelmann, executive director of the New York-based Drug Policy
Alliance, which backs such treatment-alternative measures, said, "Noelle
has a problem with drugs. What she needs is help. If one form of treatment
does not work, the answer is not prison, but to try another form of
treatment, and if that doesn't work, then another form again. Think about
this as a medical problem, or a psychological problem. No one 'treatment'
approach works for everyone." Indeed, unless the Noelles out there actually
harm others or put others at great risk, such as by driving under the
influence of drugs, we should be able to do better than prison.

Our hearts should go out to Noelle Bush, but we should not stop there.
Nonviolent drug abusers don't need jail; they need help. Our war on drugs
need not be a war on the victims.