News (Media Awareness Project) - CN BC: PUB LTE: No Cause-And Effect Between Pot And Mental |
Title: | CN BC: PUB LTE: No Cause-And Effect Between Pot And Mental |
Published On: | 2003-04-24 |
Source: | Vancouver Sun (CN BC) |
Fetched On: | 2008-01-20 19:05:32 |
NO CAUSE-AND EFFECT BETWEEN POT AND MENTAL ILLNESS
While I agree with Frank Sterle Jr.'s contention that there is a lot of
media misinformation about cannabis, I must point out that assertions such
as his -- that "pot-consumers' mental health depends in part on the
reduction or prevention of cannabis consumption" -- are part of the problem
(Pot can exacerbate some mental illness, Letters, April 23).
The study cited by Mr. Sterle reported a positive correlation between
levels of marijuana use and symptom chronicity among schizophrenics. Such
studies can tell us nothing about the cause-and-effect relations between
the correlated terms. Perhaps cannabis worsens schizophrenia, or chronic
schizophrenics are more likely to try self-medicating with marijuana, or a
third factor affects both cannabis use and schizophrenia.
Even if marijuana use does negatively affect schizophrenics, this casts no
light on the effects of cannabis on non-schizophrenics. Public policy on
recreational drugs should be based on a clear understanding of the complex
biological, psychological and social contexts involved, not on
misinterpreted research outcomes.
Dr. Leonard George
Vancouver
While I agree with Frank Sterle Jr.'s contention that there is a lot of
media misinformation about cannabis, I must point out that assertions such
as his -- that "pot-consumers' mental health depends in part on the
reduction or prevention of cannabis consumption" -- are part of the problem
(Pot can exacerbate some mental illness, Letters, April 23).
The study cited by Mr. Sterle reported a positive correlation between
levels of marijuana use and symptom chronicity among schizophrenics. Such
studies can tell us nothing about the cause-and-effect relations between
the correlated terms. Perhaps cannabis worsens schizophrenia, or chronic
schizophrenics are more likely to try self-medicating with marijuana, or a
third factor affects both cannabis use and schizophrenia.
Even if marijuana use does negatively affect schizophrenics, this casts no
light on the effects of cannabis on non-schizophrenics. Public policy on
recreational drugs should be based on a clear understanding of the complex
biological, psychological and social contexts involved, not on
misinterpreted research outcomes.
Dr. Leonard George
Vancouver
Member Comments |
No member comments available...