THE DEATH OF CLAYTON HELRIGGLE

A Deadly Raid

Shooting Prompts Questions About Lack of Training, Poor Planning, And
an Encounter at an Eaton Bar

EATON - After an evening of heavy drinking on Sept. 17, off-duty Preble
County sheriff's Deputy Terry Petitt flirted with a group of men half her
age at the 230 Club in downtown Eaton, paying special attention to
23-year-old Clayton Helriggle, witnesses said.

"(Petitt) wanted us to touch the hole in her jeans," located in the upper
thigh area, Tim Suter, a high school classmate of Helriggle's who was at
the bar that night, later told investigators.

Petitt, 44, "really took a liking to Clayton," Suter said.

Before Petitt threw up into a wastebasket and was taken home, Suter said,
she hugged and kissed the three men at the far end of the bar -- Suter,
Helriggle and his roommate Ian Albert -- and exchanged sexual banter.

Petitt told the group "she was getting divorced," Suter said. "She
mentioned she had a son our age -- the age thing was an issue. She could
teach us young (guys) a few things."

Ten days later, on Sept. 27, Helriggle lay dead in an ill-fated drug raid
led by Petitt's husband, Detective George Petitt Jr., 54, then commander of
the Preble County Emergency Services Unit. Terry Petitt, too, was in on the
raid, assigned to guard the perimeter of the house at 1282 Ohio 503, south
of West Alexandria.

Minutes after the shooting, Terry Petitt trained her weapon on a
blood-soaked Albert, in whose arms Helriggle died inside the house.

Terry and George Petitt have not commented about the events of Sept. 27,
and the days leading up to it. But an 800-page supplemental report of more
than 50 interviews by the Montgomery County Sheriff's Office special
investigations unit, reveals previously undisclosed details about the scope
of the failed planning and execution that resulted in Helriggle's death.

Members of the main entry team had just four hours of tactical training in
the nine months leading up to the raid. Others at the Helriggle farmhouse
that evening had never trained with the team, and found themselves in
unfamiliar roles as the plan changed during the critical early moments. The
information used to obtain a search warrant was largely based on overheard
conversations, a few hours of surveillance and the word of a convicted
felon who had recently lied to a court to remain free on bond.

One expert said more small, rural police departments, using mostly
inexperienced and largely untrained officers, are practicing a dangerous
game: urban, guerilla-like warfare. He calls it the "militarizing of Mayberry."

"(Preble's unit) certainly fits the dangers of jumping into something like
this with no real training," said Peter B. Kraska, a University of Eastern
Kentucky criminal justice professor.

The use of special weapons teams to force their way into private residences
"should occur only when you have overwhelming evidence that this is a large
drug operation and the people inside are known to be armed and dangerous,"
Kraska said. "That kind of situation comes up very infrequently; hardly
ever in small communities."

A grand jury concluded that no police officer engaged in criminal
wrongdoing, nor did any of Helriggle's four roommates. A Montgomery County
sheriff's investigation also determined that Helriggle had a gun -- not a
plastic cup as a witness first claimed -- when he descended the stairs
during the commotion of the raid.

But an administrative review has been launched of the mistakes that
contributed to the fatal shooting, and the victim's family is pursuing
legal action.

Investigators also examined whether George Petitt had a hidden motive for
pursuing a drug raid at the Helriggle house: his wife's friendliness toward
Helriggle on Sept. 17 at the 230 Club.

During a Nov. 1 interview with Montgomery County sheriff's investigators,
Terry Petitt acknowledged being at the 230 Club but initially denied having
any "contact" with Helriggle.

Later, in the same interview, she said she knew Helriggle was at the bar
and recognized Albert when he was led from the house the night of the
shooting.

Montgomery County Sheriff's Detective Greg Laravie then asked: "At any time
did you discuss what happened in the 230 Club with your husband as far as
seeing Clayton Helriggle?"

"Absolutely," she said. "He knew all about it."

"Did he know about it prior to the search warrant?" Laravie asked.

"I don't know," she said. ". . . I'm not sure if George and I were
separated at that time or not. I don't recall."

In his interview with sheriff's detectives Nov. 12, George Petitt Jr. said
he knew nothing about his wife's encounter with Helriggle during the
planning stages for the raid.

"I was unaware that my wife was even at the bar until after the search
warrant was issued and conducted, and the other part about holes in the
pants or something, this is my first knowledge I have about that at all."

Details of the Search Warrant

The informant said Kevin Leitch was planning yet another burglary.

Leitch, 21, was well known to Officer Jeff Cotner, Eaton's only detective,
and Cotner spent hours looking for him before spotting his car on Sinclair
Street in Eaton about 12:30 a.m. Sept. 26.

Leitch was free on bail and awaiting sentencing on more than a dozen
residential burglaries in the county. The informant said Leitch and an
accomplice were planning another heist, this time at an old farmhouse that
four young men and one girlfriend were renting at 1282 Ohio 503.

The house was said to contain 10 to 15 pounds of marijuana every weekend,
according to the informant.

Hours before pulling Leitch over, Cotner enlisted the help of Preble County
sheriff's Detective George Petitt Jr., who often assisted in city
investigations. As Cotner patrolled the streets looking for Leitch, Petitt
conducted surveillance on the farmhouse.

Cotner searched Leitch's car and found two rifles and a handgun, all of
them stolen. A passenger in the car, 18-year-old Samantha "Sammie" Webster,
was released and never questioned by Preble County officials. Sammie was
the younger sister of Tasha Webster, who lived at the farmhouse with her
boyfriend, Wesley Bradley.

After he was arrested and booked into the Preble County Jail, Leitch told
Cotner he drove Webster to the farmhouse twice that week to buy small
quantities of marijuana. He told the detective the house included up to 12
people, two to three dogs and "pounds and pounds of marijuana," Cotner
recalled to sheriff's investigators.

Cotner said he believed Leitch, even though he was seeking to revoke his
bond after learning he had lied to the court about pursuing classes at
Sinclair Community College and caring for his infirmed grandfather.

"Surprisingly, I consider Leitch real reliable to the way he has confessed
his life away," Cotner told investigators. "He trusts me like you wouldn't
believe."

Meanwhile, George Petitt was parked at the American Legion on Ohio 503 and
watching traffic go in and out of the nearby farmhouse property. Another
officer was parked nearby.

"(Petitt's) impression right off," Cotner told investigators, was that
"'this is a dope house, just by the activity.' "

Petitt told investigators: "I'd see cars coming and going. I'd pull out to
attempt to get a license plate number. From where I was sitting, I wasn't
able to really observe the house but simply the flow of traffic in and out
of that property."

Although Petitt was in charge of planning the raid, he told investigators
he didn't have first-hand knowledge of anyone selling marijuana from the house.

Nor did he know who had allegedly bought any drugs there.

"Was there any marijuana in evidence that was placed in your evidence room
or Eaton police evidence room that was purchased in one of these buys?"
Detective Laravie asked him.

"Not to my knowledge," Petitt said.

Helriggle, 23, awakened by all the commotion and armed with a handgun,
peeled down the back stairs.

George Petitt III then saw 42-year-old ESU Team Leader Kent S. Moore, a
Lewisburg police sergeant, fall over on his butt as if he'd been shot.

"At that time, I was not sure if he was hit or not," Petitt III told
investigators. "I didn't know what caused him to go to the ground that fast
and then within an instant or a second is when I seen him in a control
fashion, lift the shotgun up and fire the shot."

From a crouching position, Moore fired a single shot to Helriggle's chest,
killing him.

"I saw (Helriggle) slumped over," Petitt III said. "He was on the ground."

Moore, who still wasn't sure if he'd been wounded, stood and joined other
officers as they made their way through the house. Medics examined the
officer later and found him unharmed.

The raid was over in less than two minutes.

Among the first on the scene were Michael and Sharon Helriggle, Clayton
Helriggle's parents, who heard the call for Care Flight on their home scanner.

Preble County Prosecutor's Investigator Dave Lindloff, also the assistant
coroner, began video recording the scene minutes after the shooting.

On the tape, obtained by the Dayton Daily News, a cell phone is heard and a
dispatcher announces the time as Lindloff approaches the back door. It is
7:08 p.m.

Lindloff then announces that he ordered Lewisburg paramedic Kenny Pierce
and James Williams, a Lewisburg police officer, to "stay exactly with the
body till we can take control of the situation."

Stepping into the kitchen, Lindloff focuses the camera on a somber-faced
Pierce, who is kneeling. Pierce, who was on call outside the house before
the raid, was brought into the house to assist shortly after Helriggle was
shot.

Before the shooting, Helriggle's roommate, Ian Albert, had been ordered to
the floor at the base of the kitchen stairs by police. After the shooting,
Albert pulled his friend down to him and applied pressure to the wound.

Pierce arrived and cut Helriggle's blood-soaked blue T-shirt from his body
and applied a tourniquet -- too late to help him -- to Helriggle's right arm.

The camera scans the stairs, stopping on the fifth step where the handgun
Helriggle carried, rests. A slipper is on the sixth step.

Lindloff scans the kitchen, showing the doorway leading to the bathroom.

He ends the tape by ordering officers to "stay at the back door to be sure
no one comes in, either."

Later, as dark descended, Preble County Assistant Dog Warden Lee Richardson
was called to lock up the loose dogs so the dead man's body could be
removed from the kitchen. When Richardson shone his flashlight on the
table, the shadows revealed two dogs, guarding, prone at Helriggle's side.

Unit Disbanded

Sheriff Hayes disbanded the Emergency Services Unit shortly after the
shooting, citing financial constraints.

Hayes also relegated Detective Petitt to road patrol after he was observed
in November spending work hours at the American Legion and falsifying time
cards. Petitt did not return to work and retired on medical disability
March 28.

Terry Petitt told investigators that the couple had reconciled shortly
before the shooting, but split up again a month later.

"I have had little contact with him since Oct. 22," she told investigators.

Kristi Deaton, a Preble County corrections officer who accompanied Terry
Petitt and Camden Mayor Jerry Wood to the 230 Club on Sept. 17, told
investigators she drank Pepsi throughout the evening but that Petitt was
"highly intoxicated."

At one point, she said, Petitt brought Helriggle over to where she and Wood
were sitting. "She just introduced him as Clayton, and she had made the
comment that, 'did you know he could be my son?' " Deaton said.

Although Deaton noted she may have seen Petitt hug Helriggle, "It wasn't
anything emotional," she said. "It was just . . . when friends get together
and you give them a hug and stuff like that."

Deaton said she never questioned Petitt about her behavior that night.

"I figured she's a big girl," Deaton said. "She knows what she's doing. If
she wants to flirt, then she can flirt. If she wants to chat with them she
can."

After the shooting, Hayes called in the Montgomery County special
investigations unit, which spent 4 1/2 months interviewing dozens of
witnesses. The report was turned over to Greene County prosecutors, who
presented the case to a grand jury. The grand jury declined to indict
anybody in connection with the raid, which netted a small amount of marijuana.

Hayes also asked Montgomery County Sheriff Dave Vore to conduct an internal
administrative review into the events leading up to the raid and its fatal
consequences, including the amount of training for officers and the
issuance of search warrants.

Sgt. John Brands said his special services unit will not make
recommendations to Hayes, "but we'll point out issues we came across. It
will be up to Preble County to make decisions on anything they want to do."

The Helriggle family said it plans to file a civil lawsuit and hired James
Swaim of Dayton and David Ewing of Louisville, Ky., as its legal counsel.

Helriggle's mother, Sharon, said her son's death remains fresh, his memory
alive.

"I always think of him," she said. "He's never off my mind, first thing
getting up or when I'm up in the middle of the night pacing the house. It
doesn't go away. It doesn't get any better."

She said she doesn't blame the man who shot her son. "I never had any
hatred in my heart for him. But someone should have said, 'whoa,' and
stopped it. There was no rush."

Sgt. Moore, the Lewisburg officer who fired the fatal shotgun blast and who
was placed on desk duty after the raid, returned to his job as a supervisor
in February.

In his interview with investigators, Moore gave a vivid account of the
chaotic seconds when he heard Helriggle on the stairs saying, "What the
(expletive) is going on down here?" and holding a gun in his right hand
"with his finger in the trigger guard."

"Do you feel that you were in imminent danger of your life when you
discharged your service weapon?" Detective Rick Ward asked him.

"Yes, he was going to kill me," Moore said.

The raid changed how some officers view their jobs.

Greg McWhinney, a former corrections officer who had been a full-time
sheriff's road deputy only four months when he was deployed to the
Helriggle house, told investigators the trip from the farmhouse after the
shooting was "dead freaking silence."

"That is the first one of those I had ever seen and I will be honest: I
felt like puking my guts out," McWhinney said.

For others, the raid became a dim memory, best forgotten.

"I have kind of put it out of my mind for so long now that some of the
details are a bit sketchy," George Petitt III, the detective's son who
watched Helriggle die, told investigators two months after the shooting.

"It's not something I try and dwell on. I'm trying to move on from it
because it wasn't pretty."

He added: "There isn't anything about it I'm proud of in any way."