News (Media Awareness Project) - UK: Web: Cannabis User Loses 'Pain' Appeal |
Title: | UK: Web: Cannabis User Loses 'Pain' Appeal |
Published On: | 2003-09-19 |
Source: | BBC News (UK Web) |
Fetched On: | 2008-01-19 11:51:09 |
CANNABIS USER LOSES 'PAIN' APPEAL
A man who used cannabis to relieve chronic pain in his joints has failed to
overturn his conviction for growing the drug in a bedroom.
On Friday, the Appeal Court refused Peter Brown, 45, of Lark Rise,
Blackthorn, Northampton, permission to challenge his conviction.
Brown, 45, of Lark Rise, Blackthorn, was given a two-year conditional
discharge last December at Northampton Crown Court after admitting he had
grown cannabis.
Brown, on crutches, briefly argued his case before Lord Justice Kay, Mr
Justice Silber and Mr Justice Leveson, who already had read written
submissions.
But Mr Justice Leveson refused his application, rejecting claims about his
proposed defence and the argument that his human rights had been breached.
Cannabis a 'necessity'
Brown argued that cannabis was a "necessity" to him because of his need to
take the drug for chronic pain.
He said lawful medication either did not work or left him with adverse
side-effects.
After considering arguments and documents, including medical reports and
Brown's police interview, the court ruled the facts did not give rise to a
defence which could properly be left to a jury.
In December 2001, police went to Brown's home and he took them to an
upstairs bedroom where cannabis plants were growing using a hydroponics
system.
Mr Justice Leveson said the defence of necessity or duress was available in
cases - when viewed objectively - it was found a person faced death or
serious injury.
Brown said his pain put him in the serious injury category, but Mr Justice
Leveson noted the evidence made it clear it was possible for him to control
his pain through legitimate means.
Brown told the BBC that he now intends to take his case to the European
courts.
A man who used cannabis to relieve chronic pain in his joints has failed to
overturn his conviction for growing the drug in a bedroom.
On Friday, the Appeal Court refused Peter Brown, 45, of Lark Rise,
Blackthorn, Northampton, permission to challenge his conviction.
Brown, 45, of Lark Rise, Blackthorn, was given a two-year conditional
discharge last December at Northampton Crown Court after admitting he had
grown cannabis.
Brown, on crutches, briefly argued his case before Lord Justice Kay, Mr
Justice Silber and Mr Justice Leveson, who already had read written
submissions.
But Mr Justice Leveson refused his application, rejecting claims about his
proposed defence and the argument that his human rights had been breached.
Cannabis a 'necessity'
Brown argued that cannabis was a "necessity" to him because of his need to
take the drug for chronic pain.
He said lawful medication either did not work or left him with adverse
side-effects.
After considering arguments and documents, including medical reports and
Brown's police interview, the court ruled the facts did not give rise to a
defence which could properly be left to a jury.
In December 2001, police went to Brown's home and he took them to an
upstairs bedroom where cannabis plants were growing using a hydroponics
system.
Mr Justice Leveson said the defence of necessity or duress was available in
cases - when viewed objectively - it was found a person faced death or
serious injury.
Brown said his pain put him in the serious injury category, but Mr Justice
Leveson noted the evidence made it clear it was possible for him to control
his pain through legitimate means.
Brown told the BBC that he now intends to take his case to the European
courts.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...