News (Media Awareness Project) - Russia: Animal Lovers Favor Drug Legalization |
Title: | Russia: Animal Lovers Favor Drug Legalization |
Published On: | 2003-12-25 |
Source: | Moscow Times, The (Russia) |
Fetched On: | 2008-01-19 02:24:24 |
ANIMAL LOVERS FAVOR DRUG LEGALIZATION
Two men walk into a clinic to get their cat spayed.
What sounds like the opening line of a dubious joke is in fact the
beginning of one of many criminal investigations that has left
veterinarians and animal lovers up in arms.
According to the owner of a Moscow pet clinic, when the vet brought
out a syringe to give the cat in question a shot, the men identified
themselves as agents of a narcotics squad -- and raided the premises
for a banned drug.
Together with animal rights groups, veterinarians say that the newly
formed federal anti-drug agency -- created from the now defunct tax
police -- has started prosecuting animal care-givers for using an
anesthetic widely used in the West but banned in Russia.
The drug in question, Ketamine, is known to ravers as Special
K.
But according to veterinarians it is the only widely available and
affordable anesthetic on the market -- the black market, that is.
Ketamine has been banned in Russia since 1998, when the Agriculture
Ministry neglected to include it on its list of approved veterinary
drugs.
Veterinarians, however, have continued using the drug for procedures
ranging from neutering to complex surgery.
Until the anti-narcotics agency stepped up its crackdown three months
ago, vets relied on shady importers for Ketamine. But now many clinics
are refusing to treat pets that desperately need operations, animal
rights activists say.
"Doctors are stuck between a rock and a hard place," said Irina
Novozhilova, president of Vita Center, an animal rights
organization.
"If they operate without using an anesthetic, they can be charged with
cruelty to animals and are breaking their doctor's oath to do no
harm," she said. "But if they use Ketamine they can face a criminal
penalty for drug possession."
Some vets have tried performing operations using only drugs that
immobilize the sick animal but do not make it lose
consciousness.
"I witnessed a cat being sterilized in this way, and it was terrible.
It was convulsing from the pain," Novozhilova said.
Veterinarians say raids by narcotics committee agents started at the
beginning of the year and have intensified in the past three months.
Many have resulted in the confiscation of Ketamine and suspended
prison sentences. It is possible that many more cases never make it to
court.
The owner of the Moscow clinic that was raided by agents posing as cat
owners said he only avoided prosecution by paying a bribe.
The vet, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the raid turned up
Ketamine.
"Unfortunately one of the doctors had left a bottle out of its hiding
place and they found it," he said. "We already knew they were
tightening the screws, so we don't usually keep our supplies in the
clinic anymore."
Although the vet was told he could face a sentence of up to five years
in prison, he was never charged. He arranged for an "out-of-court
settlement," he said, by paying off agents several thousand dollars at
their Moscow headquarters.
The anti-drug agency is unsympathetic to such stories.
"If there was a problem, then it can be reported through the official
channels," said Vasily Sorokin, first deputy head of the Moscow City
division of the agency. "We have an internal security department which
deals with these kinds of issues."
The agency is making no plans to loosen up on veterinarians who use
Ketamine.
"It's a controlled substance. What do you expect us to do, just let
them use an illegal drug?" said Sorokin
He said he was not convinced that vets have no viable options for
anesthetics besides Ketamine.
"The Agriculture Ministry is well aware of the situation, but they
have not done anything to change the drug status," Sorokin said. "They
have a whole list of other drugs that can be used."
Veterinarians say criminalization will not solve the problem of
Ketamine distribution and have called on the Agriculture Ministry to
legalize its use.
"The only thing criminalization has done is cause people to take their
pets to unlicensed doctors who are not on the authorities' radar
screen," said Alexander Tkachyov, owner of the Maved clinic and head
of the Veterinary Association.
"Not only that, but this is causing the illegal Ketamine market to
boom because pet owners know that vets may not have the drug
available. So they are stocking up on it themselves, just in case
something happens."
"This whole situation is the result of a mess-up by the Agriculture
Ministry, which, for some inexplicable reason, forgot to include
Ketamine on its list of approved drugs and has done nothing to change
that."
The Agriculture Ministry did not respond to a request for clarification.
Two men walk into a clinic to get their cat spayed.
What sounds like the opening line of a dubious joke is in fact the
beginning of one of many criminal investigations that has left
veterinarians and animal lovers up in arms.
According to the owner of a Moscow pet clinic, when the vet brought
out a syringe to give the cat in question a shot, the men identified
themselves as agents of a narcotics squad -- and raided the premises
for a banned drug.
Together with animal rights groups, veterinarians say that the newly
formed federal anti-drug agency -- created from the now defunct tax
police -- has started prosecuting animal care-givers for using an
anesthetic widely used in the West but banned in Russia.
The drug in question, Ketamine, is known to ravers as Special
K.
But according to veterinarians it is the only widely available and
affordable anesthetic on the market -- the black market, that is.
Ketamine has been banned in Russia since 1998, when the Agriculture
Ministry neglected to include it on its list of approved veterinary
drugs.
Veterinarians, however, have continued using the drug for procedures
ranging from neutering to complex surgery.
Until the anti-narcotics agency stepped up its crackdown three months
ago, vets relied on shady importers for Ketamine. But now many clinics
are refusing to treat pets that desperately need operations, animal
rights activists say.
"Doctors are stuck between a rock and a hard place," said Irina
Novozhilova, president of Vita Center, an animal rights
organization.
"If they operate without using an anesthetic, they can be charged with
cruelty to animals and are breaking their doctor's oath to do no
harm," she said. "But if they use Ketamine they can face a criminal
penalty for drug possession."
Some vets have tried performing operations using only drugs that
immobilize the sick animal but do not make it lose
consciousness.
"I witnessed a cat being sterilized in this way, and it was terrible.
It was convulsing from the pain," Novozhilova said.
Veterinarians say raids by narcotics committee agents started at the
beginning of the year and have intensified in the past three months.
Many have resulted in the confiscation of Ketamine and suspended
prison sentences. It is possible that many more cases never make it to
court.
The owner of the Moscow clinic that was raided by agents posing as cat
owners said he only avoided prosecution by paying a bribe.
The vet, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the raid turned up
Ketamine.
"Unfortunately one of the doctors had left a bottle out of its hiding
place and they found it," he said. "We already knew they were
tightening the screws, so we don't usually keep our supplies in the
clinic anymore."
Although the vet was told he could face a sentence of up to five years
in prison, he was never charged. He arranged for an "out-of-court
settlement," he said, by paying off agents several thousand dollars at
their Moscow headquarters.
The anti-drug agency is unsympathetic to such stories.
"If there was a problem, then it can be reported through the official
channels," said Vasily Sorokin, first deputy head of the Moscow City
division of the agency. "We have an internal security department which
deals with these kinds of issues."
The agency is making no plans to loosen up on veterinarians who use
Ketamine.
"It's a controlled substance. What do you expect us to do, just let
them use an illegal drug?" said Sorokin
He said he was not convinced that vets have no viable options for
anesthetics besides Ketamine.
"The Agriculture Ministry is well aware of the situation, but they
have not done anything to change the drug status," Sorokin said. "They
have a whole list of other drugs that can be used."
Veterinarians say criminalization will not solve the problem of
Ketamine distribution and have called on the Agriculture Ministry to
legalize its use.
"The only thing criminalization has done is cause people to take their
pets to unlicensed doctors who are not on the authorities' radar
screen," said Alexander Tkachyov, owner of the Maved clinic and head
of the Veterinary Association.
"Not only that, but this is causing the illegal Ketamine market to
boom because pet owners know that vets may not have the drug
available. So they are stocking up on it themselves, just in case
something happens."
"This whole situation is the result of a mess-up by the Agriculture
Ministry, which, for some inexplicable reason, forgot to include
Ketamine on its list of approved drugs and has done nothing to change
that."
The Agriculture Ministry did not respond to a request for clarification.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...