News (Media Awareness Project) - CN BC: PUB LTE: Letter: Landlords Are Not To Blame |
Title: | CN BC: PUB LTE: Letter: Landlords Are Not To Blame |
Published On: | 2005-10-18 |
Source: | Parksville Qualicum Beach News (CN BC) |
Fetched On: | 2008-01-15 10:51:58 |
LANDLORDS ARE NOT TO BLAME
What is it about regulators and public bureaucracies that forces them to
ignore simple principles of justice when they decide that yet another body
of regulations must be rammed down our throats?
In this case, I am referring to the proposal that Parksville adopt a set of
regulations punishing landlords should they fail to act promptly if the
property they own is used by a tenant for improper purposes, in this
particular case, the production of illegal drugs on those premises
There are two things wrong with such regulations. In the first place, they
are self-contradictory.
Existing laws protect tenants from any improper snooping by landlords,
thereby making it illegal and impossible for landlords to enter premises
without warning and to examine the furnishings, incoming and outgoing mail
and other tenants' possessions.
How then are landlords supposed to glean sufficient information on tenants
to justify violating these regulations
Second, the law flies in the face of simple justice.
When a tenant applies to occupy an apartment or other rental housing, the
only reasonable presumption is that the tenant wishes to live there in a
normal manner and landlords judge them on that basis.
Therefore, if a tenant makes such an application and then violates the
terms of the leasing agreement by producing illegal substances, it is the
tenant that is the liar, it is the tenant who behaves improperly and the
only party, therefore, that should be punished in any way is the tenant
This proposed regulation should be rejected out of hand without further
consideration
Leonard Melma
Nanoose Bay
What is it about regulators and public bureaucracies that forces them to
ignore simple principles of justice when they decide that yet another body
of regulations must be rammed down our throats?
In this case, I am referring to the proposal that Parksville adopt a set of
regulations punishing landlords should they fail to act promptly if the
property they own is used by a tenant for improper purposes, in this
particular case, the production of illegal drugs on those premises
There are two things wrong with such regulations. In the first place, they
are self-contradictory.
Existing laws protect tenants from any improper snooping by landlords,
thereby making it illegal and impossible for landlords to enter premises
without warning and to examine the furnishings, incoming and outgoing mail
and other tenants' possessions.
How then are landlords supposed to glean sufficient information on tenants
to justify violating these regulations
Second, the law flies in the face of simple justice.
When a tenant applies to occupy an apartment or other rental housing, the
only reasonable presumption is that the tenant wishes to live there in a
normal manner and landlords judge them on that basis.
Therefore, if a tenant makes such an application and then violates the
terms of the leasing agreement by producing illegal substances, it is the
tenant that is the liar, it is the tenant who behaves improperly and the
only party, therefore, that should be punished in any way is the tenant
This proposed regulation should be rejected out of hand without further
consideration
Leonard Melma
Nanoose Bay
Member Comments |
No member comments available...