News (Media Awareness Project) - US MA: SJC Declines To Act On Gun, Drug Seizure |
Title: | US MA: SJC Declines To Act On Gun, Drug Seizure |
Published On: | 2006-03-08 |
Source: | Worcester Telegram & Gazette (MA) |
Fetched On: | 2008-01-14 14:48:38 |
SJC DECLINES TO ACT ON GUN, DRUG SEIZURE
WORCESTER-- A state Appeals Court ruling that a police officer acted
properly when he seized a gun and drugs from a Worcester man three
years ago has been allowed to stand.
Reversing a Superior Court judge's suppression of evidence decision,
the Appeals Court ruled on Dec. 19 that Worcester police Officer
Carmelo Oquendo acted "within permissible bounds" when he seized a
handgun, cocaine and marijuana from Luis O. Vega on the afternoon of
May 30, 2003.
Sean J. Gallagher, a lawyer representing Mr. Vega, filed an
application for further appellate review to the state Supreme
Judicial Court Jan. 12. The application was denied by the state's
highest court March 1, according to court records. The denial allowed
the Appeals Court decision to stand.
Mr. Vega, 23, of 5 King St., had been held on $50,000 cash bail on
firearm and drug charges pending against him in Worcester Superior
Court as a result of his 2003 arrest. On Sept. 6, 2004, Judge John S.
McCann allowed a motion to suppress evidence in Mr. Vega's case that
had been filed by his lawyer, David L. Cataldo. The judge found that
Officer Oquendo, a 10-year veteran of the Worcester police gang unit,
was "simply operating on a hunch" when he stopped Mr. Vega near the
corner of Main and King streets and found a .22-caliber handgun,
cocaine and marijuana on him.
Officer Oquendo lacked reasonable suspicion to stop Mr. Vega and the
stop and seizure were therefore illegal, according to Judge McCann's ruling.
On Oct. 1, 2004, Judge McCann released Mr. Vega from custody on
personal recognizance. Mr. Cataldo had requested a bail reduction in
light of the suppression ruling. As conditions of his release, Mr.
Vega was ordered to remain drug-free and to keep away from guns.
On June 6, Mr. Vega was charged with murder in the June 4 shooting
death of 30-year-old Luis A. Rosario of Milford in the Great Brook
Valley housing project. He is now being held in custody without bail
on the murder charge, which is also pending in Worcester Superior
Court and has been continued to April 3.
According to a transcript of Officer Oquendo's testimony during a
hearing on the motion to suppress in the gun and drug case, Mr. Vega
was among a group of men blocking the sidewalk at Main and King
streets on the afternoon of May 30, 2003. The officer described the
area as one of the city's "hot spots" for criminal activity.
Officer Oquendo testified that he and other members of the gang unit
approached the group in a cruiser, intending to disperse the crowd.
As he and the other officers got closer, Mr. Vega, who was talking on
a cell phone, turned and looked in the direction of the cruiser,
according to Officer Oquendo.
He said Mr. Vega then turned away, switched the cell phone to his
left hand, reached toward his waist area with his right hand and
began to walk off. The officer testified that he exited the cruiser
and called out to Mr. Vega, who continued to walk away. Officer
Oquendo said he called out to Mr. Vega again and Mr. Vega turned
around and began to approach him.
It was at that point, the officer said, that he noticed a "bulge" in
the area of Mr. Vega's waist. Officer Oquendo testified that he
conducted a "pat frisk," found the handgun, determined that Mr. Vega
did not have a license to carry the weapon and arrested him. He said
he then discovered the drugs in Mr. Vega's pockets.
While Judge McCann found the stop-and-search to be unlawful, the
Appeals Court said the circumstances of the case, particularly Mr.
Vega's "arm movement toward his waist," justified the stop. The
appellate court further found Officer Oquendo was "authorized, after
making the stop, to pat-frisk the defendant for the officer's protection."
Mr. Vega is due back in court today on the gun and drug charges.
WORCESTER-- A state Appeals Court ruling that a police officer acted
properly when he seized a gun and drugs from a Worcester man three
years ago has been allowed to stand.
Reversing a Superior Court judge's suppression of evidence decision,
the Appeals Court ruled on Dec. 19 that Worcester police Officer
Carmelo Oquendo acted "within permissible bounds" when he seized a
handgun, cocaine and marijuana from Luis O. Vega on the afternoon of
May 30, 2003.
Sean J. Gallagher, a lawyer representing Mr. Vega, filed an
application for further appellate review to the state Supreme
Judicial Court Jan. 12. The application was denied by the state's
highest court March 1, according to court records. The denial allowed
the Appeals Court decision to stand.
Mr. Vega, 23, of 5 King St., had been held on $50,000 cash bail on
firearm and drug charges pending against him in Worcester Superior
Court as a result of his 2003 arrest. On Sept. 6, 2004, Judge John S.
McCann allowed a motion to suppress evidence in Mr. Vega's case that
had been filed by his lawyer, David L. Cataldo. The judge found that
Officer Oquendo, a 10-year veteran of the Worcester police gang unit,
was "simply operating on a hunch" when he stopped Mr. Vega near the
corner of Main and King streets and found a .22-caliber handgun,
cocaine and marijuana on him.
Officer Oquendo lacked reasonable suspicion to stop Mr. Vega and the
stop and seizure were therefore illegal, according to Judge McCann's ruling.
On Oct. 1, 2004, Judge McCann released Mr. Vega from custody on
personal recognizance. Mr. Cataldo had requested a bail reduction in
light of the suppression ruling. As conditions of his release, Mr.
Vega was ordered to remain drug-free and to keep away from guns.
On June 6, Mr. Vega was charged with murder in the June 4 shooting
death of 30-year-old Luis A. Rosario of Milford in the Great Brook
Valley housing project. He is now being held in custody without bail
on the murder charge, which is also pending in Worcester Superior
Court and has been continued to April 3.
According to a transcript of Officer Oquendo's testimony during a
hearing on the motion to suppress in the gun and drug case, Mr. Vega
was among a group of men blocking the sidewalk at Main and King
streets on the afternoon of May 30, 2003. The officer described the
area as one of the city's "hot spots" for criminal activity.
Officer Oquendo testified that he and other members of the gang unit
approached the group in a cruiser, intending to disperse the crowd.
As he and the other officers got closer, Mr. Vega, who was talking on
a cell phone, turned and looked in the direction of the cruiser,
according to Officer Oquendo.
He said Mr. Vega then turned away, switched the cell phone to his
left hand, reached toward his waist area with his right hand and
began to walk off. The officer testified that he exited the cruiser
and called out to Mr. Vega, who continued to walk away. Officer
Oquendo said he called out to Mr. Vega again and Mr. Vega turned
around and began to approach him.
It was at that point, the officer said, that he noticed a "bulge" in
the area of Mr. Vega's waist. Officer Oquendo testified that he
conducted a "pat frisk," found the handgun, determined that Mr. Vega
did not have a license to carry the weapon and arrested him. He said
he then discovered the drugs in Mr. Vega's pockets.
While Judge McCann found the stop-and-search to be unlawful, the
Appeals Court said the circumstances of the case, particularly Mr.
Vega's "arm movement toward his waist," justified the stop. The
appellate court further found Officer Oquendo was "authorized, after
making the stop, to pat-frisk the defendant for the officer's protection."
Mr. Vega is due back in court today on the gun and drug charges.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...