News (Media Awareness Project) - Mexico: Poll Results Mixed For Mexico's PRI |
Title: | Mexico: Poll Results Mixed For Mexico's PRI |
Published On: | 2010-07-06 |
Source: | Wall Street Journal (US) |
Fetched On: | 2010-07-06 15:01:05 |
POLL RESULTS MIXED FOR MEXICO'S PRI
After Nearly A Decade On Sidelines, Party Does Well In State Elections
MEXICO CITY-Mexico's former ruling party won a majority of states up
for grabs in weekend elections, but its losses in three bastions left
analysts questioning the party's momentum as it hopes to retake the
presidency in 2012.
The Institutional Revolutionary Party, or PRI, which governed Mexico
for 71 years until 2000, won nine of 12 states that elected new
governors on Sunday, according to preliminary results. It picked up
three states where it had been out of power for 12 years. The party
also won in big border cities including Tijuana and Ciudad Juarez.
But it lost three big states where it had governed for generations:
Sinaloa, Oaxaca and Puebla. In each case, the PRI lost to candidates
fielded by an alliance between the conservative National Action Party,
or PAN, and the left-wing Party of the Democratic Revolution.
The PRI has been on a roll in the past two years, capitalizing on a
weak economy and rising drug-related violence to become the
front-runner to retake the presidency in 2012 elections. The PAN and
PRD felt they had no choice but to put aside recent grievances and
linked up forces to stop the PRI from winning all 12 gubernatorial
races.
The election showed the PRI's resurgence could have its limits. "Those
are three big states. It hurts," said Daniel Lund, a pollster with the
Mexico City-based The Mund Group.
The PRI suffered from an image of corruption and strong-arm rule in
two of the key states, Oaxaca and Puebla. In Oaxaca, it was hurt by
opposition from a powerful teachers union. In 2006, after the last
governor's race, PRI Gov. Ulises Ruiz was accused of human-rights
abuses in cracking down on a teacher protest. The PRI never mended
relations.
Analysts say the governor also made few strides in changing living
standards of the state, among Mexico's poorest, which became a major
campaign issue for alliance candidate Gabino Cue. Mr. Cue won with 50%
of the vote to the PRI's 42%, preliminary results showed.
In Puebla, PRI Gov. Mario Marin's government had faced a 2006 scandal
in which he allegedly ordered state police to harass a well-known
journalist for accusing a local businessman of involvement in a
child-prostitution ring. While Mr. Marin survived the blowup, a
powerful teachers' union there broke tradition this year and sided
with PAN-PRD candidate Rafael Moreno Valle, who went on to win the
election, 52% to the PRI's 42%.
In Sinaloa, PRI candidate Jesus Vizcarra faced allegations he was tied
to drug organizations after pictures surfaced of him with one of the
heads of the state's notorious Sinaloa drug cartel. High voter
turnout-nearly 12 percentage points above the 2004 election-indicated
voters may have set out to punish Mr. Vizcarra, fearing the and
alleged corruption in the PRI, analysts say.
Sinaloa "always threatened to slip out of the PRI's hands" because the
PAN has a stronger base there than in other parts of the country, said
Mr. Lund, the pollster. Mr. Vizcarra lost to PAN-PRD candidate Mario
Lopez Valdez by six percentage points.
While political alliances between opposing parties tend to be fragile,
analysts say Mexico may explore them in years ahead given their
success this weekend. The parties are "certain to explore similar
alliances for...gubernatorial showdowns in Nayarit, Guerrero, and
Mexico State," says George W. Grayson, an expert on Mexican politics
and drug trafficking, at the College of William and Mary.
The final stretch of the race was marred by some high-profile attacks
which authorities attributed to organized crime. On June 28, hit men
opened fire on the car of Rodolfo Torre, the PRI candidate in northern
Tamaulipas state, killing the politician, members of his staff and
bodyguards. On Wednesday, a severed head was found in front of the
home of Hector Murguia, the PRI candidate for mayor of Ciudad Juarez
who declared victory Sunday.
Violence on that scale didn't resurface on Sunday. Jorge Chabat, a
drugs expert at Mexico City think-tank Center for Research and
Teaching in Economics, said he doesn't think the drug gangs have an
interest in disrupting elections on a large scale. Still, low voter
turnout in Tamaulipas indicated the attacks did have a chilling effect
on voters, Mr. Chabat said. "I don't think that was the purpose of the
attack," he added. "I think the purpose was simply to remove someone
who wasn't favorable to their interests." The PRI still dominated , as
the slain candidate's brother, Egidio Torre, ran in his place and won
62% of the vote.
After Nearly A Decade On Sidelines, Party Does Well In State Elections
MEXICO CITY-Mexico's former ruling party won a majority of states up
for grabs in weekend elections, but its losses in three bastions left
analysts questioning the party's momentum as it hopes to retake the
presidency in 2012.
The Institutional Revolutionary Party, or PRI, which governed Mexico
for 71 years until 2000, won nine of 12 states that elected new
governors on Sunday, according to preliminary results. It picked up
three states where it had been out of power for 12 years. The party
also won in big border cities including Tijuana and Ciudad Juarez.
But it lost three big states where it had governed for generations:
Sinaloa, Oaxaca and Puebla. In each case, the PRI lost to candidates
fielded by an alliance between the conservative National Action Party,
or PAN, and the left-wing Party of the Democratic Revolution.
The PRI has been on a roll in the past two years, capitalizing on a
weak economy and rising drug-related violence to become the
front-runner to retake the presidency in 2012 elections. The PAN and
PRD felt they had no choice but to put aside recent grievances and
linked up forces to stop the PRI from winning all 12 gubernatorial
races.
The election showed the PRI's resurgence could have its limits. "Those
are three big states. It hurts," said Daniel Lund, a pollster with the
Mexico City-based The Mund Group.
The PRI suffered from an image of corruption and strong-arm rule in
two of the key states, Oaxaca and Puebla. In Oaxaca, it was hurt by
opposition from a powerful teachers union. In 2006, after the last
governor's race, PRI Gov. Ulises Ruiz was accused of human-rights
abuses in cracking down on a teacher protest. The PRI never mended
relations.
Analysts say the governor also made few strides in changing living
standards of the state, among Mexico's poorest, which became a major
campaign issue for alliance candidate Gabino Cue. Mr. Cue won with 50%
of the vote to the PRI's 42%, preliminary results showed.
In Puebla, PRI Gov. Mario Marin's government had faced a 2006 scandal
in which he allegedly ordered state police to harass a well-known
journalist for accusing a local businessman of involvement in a
child-prostitution ring. While Mr. Marin survived the blowup, a
powerful teachers' union there broke tradition this year and sided
with PAN-PRD candidate Rafael Moreno Valle, who went on to win the
election, 52% to the PRI's 42%.
In Sinaloa, PRI candidate Jesus Vizcarra faced allegations he was tied
to drug organizations after pictures surfaced of him with one of the
heads of the state's notorious Sinaloa drug cartel. High voter
turnout-nearly 12 percentage points above the 2004 election-indicated
voters may have set out to punish Mr. Vizcarra, fearing the and
alleged corruption in the PRI, analysts say.
Sinaloa "always threatened to slip out of the PRI's hands" because the
PAN has a stronger base there than in other parts of the country, said
Mr. Lund, the pollster. Mr. Vizcarra lost to PAN-PRD candidate Mario
Lopez Valdez by six percentage points.
While political alliances between opposing parties tend to be fragile,
analysts say Mexico may explore them in years ahead given their
success this weekend. The parties are "certain to explore similar
alliances for...gubernatorial showdowns in Nayarit, Guerrero, and
Mexico State," says George W. Grayson, an expert on Mexican politics
and drug trafficking, at the College of William and Mary.
The final stretch of the race was marred by some high-profile attacks
which authorities attributed to organized crime. On June 28, hit men
opened fire on the car of Rodolfo Torre, the PRI candidate in northern
Tamaulipas state, killing the politician, members of his staff and
bodyguards. On Wednesday, a severed head was found in front of the
home of Hector Murguia, the PRI candidate for mayor of Ciudad Juarez
who declared victory Sunday.
Violence on that scale didn't resurface on Sunday. Jorge Chabat, a
drugs expert at Mexico City think-tank Center for Research and
Teaching in Economics, said he doesn't think the drug gangs have an
interest in disrupting elections on a large scale. Still, low voter
turnout in Tamaulipas indicated the attacks did have a chilling effect
on voters, Mr. Chabat said. "I don't think that was the purpose of the
attack," he added. "I think the purpose was simply to remove someone
who wasn't favorable to their interests." The PRI still dominated , as
the slain candidate's brother, Egidio Torre, ran in his place and won
62% of the vote.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...