News (Media Awareness Project) - US FL: Editorial: Marijuana-Killing Fungus Too Risky |
Title: | US FL: Editorial: Marijuana-Killing Fungus Too Risky |
Published On: | 1999-07-20 |
Source: | St. Petersburg Times (FL) |
Fetched On: | 2008-09-06 01:37:42 |
MARIJUANA-KILLING FUNGUS TOO RISKY
Whoever first said "the cure is worse than the disease" could have
been talking about Florida's history of trying to eradicate one
environmental problem by creating a bigger one.
Now the state's new drug czar is suggesting we consider introducing a
killer fungus that will destroy the state's illicit marijuana crop.
The problem is, we don't know what else the fungus will kill.
State drug czar Jim McDonough has been holding meetings in Tallahassee
trying to drum up support for the testing of Fusarium oxysporum, a
soil-borne fungus. He wants tests to occur in a state quarantine
facility in Gainesville, where other bio-control materials are
evaluated for safety and effectiveness. Ag/Bio Con., the Montana
company that is developing the marijuana killer, says the fungus "does
not affect animals, humans or any other crops."
But scientists at the Florida Department of Environmental Protection
suggest otherwise and are warning that there could be serious
consequences for releasing the mycoherbicide. In a letter to
McDonough, DEP Secretary David Struhs expressed grave concern over the
possibility of the fungus mutating and attacking other plant species.
"Mutation of the organism would not only threaten Florida's natural
environment, but would also put at risk our economically vital
agricultural industry," Struhs wrote.
Due to Florida's warm soil conditions, a fungus can survive for as
long as 40 years.
The idea is shockingly dangerous and, even if it worked, wouldn't
affect a large portion of the marijuana grown in the state since much
of it is grown indoors. When marijuana is cultivated outdoors it is
often dispersed among crops and other plantings. Last year only 55,000
marijuana plants were confiscated throughout the state. Compare that
figure to a state such as Hawaii where a half-million plants were
confiscated in 1996.
The problem isn't severe enough to warrant the risk of releasing a
deadly marauding fungus, no matter how many laboratory tests
ultimately say the organism is safe.
Florida's past experience with introducing exotic species to tame an
environmental problem have proved disastrous. The thirsty Australian
melaleuca was introduced by government foresters to help drain the
Everglades. Now, of course, we want the Everglades protected and
rehydrated. Yet, like a pestilence, the melaleuca trees have spread
all over South Florida, drinking precious water and slowly parching
the river of grass.
Kudzu, a Chinese vine, was also brought here by the government, as a
natural erosion ontrol. It's exceptionally rapid growth of up to a
foot per day has overtaken other species.
Florida's warm climate makes it particularly vulnerable to unintended
consequences of exotic botanicals. Introducing a killer fungus with a
40-year life span into this ecosystem in order to destroy a relatively
modest marijuana crop is just not worth the risk.
Whoever first said "the cure is worse than the disease" could have
been talking about Florida's history of trying to eradicate one
environmental problem by creating a bigger one.
Now the state's new drug czar is suggesting we consider introducing a
killer fungus that will destroy the state's illicit marijuana crop.
The problem is, we don't know what else the fungus will kill.
State drug czar Jim McDonough has been holding meetings in Tallahassee
trying to drum up support for the testing of Fusarium oxysporum, a
soil-borne fungus. He wants tests to occur in a state quarantine
facility in Gainesville, where other bio-control materials are
evaluated for safety and effectiveness. Ag/Bio Con., the Montana
company that is developing the marijuana killer, says the fungus "does
not affect animals, humans or any other crops."
But scientists at the Florida Department of Environmental Protection
suggest otherwise and are warning that there could be serious
consequences for releasing the mycoherbicide. In a letter to
McDonough, DEP Secretary David Struhs expressed grave concern over the
possibility of the fungus mutating and attacking other plant species.
"Mutation of the organism would not only threaten Florida's natural
environment, but would also put at risk our economically vital
agricultural industry," Struhs wrote.
Due to Florida's warm soil conditions, a fungus can survive for as
long as 40 years.
The idea is shockingly dangerous and, even if it worked, wouldn't
affect a large portion of the marijuana grown in the state since much
of it is grown indoors. When marijuana is cultivated outdoors it is
often dispersed among crops and other plantings. Last year only 55,000
marijuana plants were confiscated throughout the state. Compare that
figure to a state such as Hawaii where a half-million plants were
confiscated in 1996.
The problem isn't severe enough to warrant the risk of releasing a
deadly marauding fungus, no matter how many laboratory tests
ultimately say the organism is safe.
Florida's past experience with introducing exotic species to tame an
environmental problem have proved disastrous. The thirsty Australian
melaleuca was introduced by government foresters to help drain the
Everglades. Now, of course, we want the Everglades protected and
rehydrated. Yet, like a pestilence, the melaleuca trees have spread
all over South Florida, drinking precious water and slowly parching
the river of grass.
Kudzu, a Chinese vine, was also brought here by the government, as a
natural erosion ontrol. It's exceptionally rapid growth of up to a
foot per day has overtaken other species.
Florida's warm climate makes it particularly vulnerable to unintended
consequences of exotic botanicals. Introducing a killer fungus with a
40-year life span into this ecosystem in order to destroy a relatively
modest marijuana crop is just not worth the risk.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...