News (Media Awareness Project) - US FL: Editorial: Regulation: High Grounds |
Title: | US FL: Editorial: Regulation: High Grounds |
Published On: | 2000-06-03 |
Source: | Metro (CA) |
Fetched On: | 2008-09-03 20:50:47 |
REGULATION: HIGH GROUNDS
City officials are allowing Florida Cannabis Action Network to use
Metropolitan Park on June 17 for a "hempfest." The group is unhappy,
however, because the city plans to charge a fee.
The group said the city waives its fee for some groups and therefore
city officials are discriminating against this group because they
don't like its pro-marijuana message.
In seeking an injunction, the group characterizes the fees as a
violation of its members' federal civil rights, including free speech.
Someone must pay expenses associated with any large gathering in a
public park, such as police protection and cleanup services. Taxpayers
absorb the costs at city-sponsored events, such as the Fourth of July
show. But sponsors of private events are billed, without exception, a
city official says.
If the event were adopted as a city-sponsored event, it could raise
constitutional questions about government giving official sanction to
one political cause over another.
The First Amendment does not guarantee "free" speech and assembly. It
guarantees "freedom of" speech and assembly. There is a major
distinction. Government must allow people to say whatever they want
about a public policy issue. But it isn't obligated to pay the cost of
spreading that message.
The cannabis group wants to solicit signatures on petitions to get a
con-stitutional amendment legalizing marijuana for medical purposes
on the 2002 statewide ballot. Only about 10 percent of the needed
signatures have been collected.
Supporters have other options if they don't want to pay fees --
telephone solicitations, direct mail and adver-tising, conducting a
door-to-door campaign or handling out fliers on the street, for example.
The "civil rights" hyperbole probably is a good campaign tactic
because it portrays marijuana advocates as underdogs in a struggle
against a big and unbending government. Legally speaking, it is merely
blowing smoke.
City officials are allowing Florida Cannabis Action Network to use
Metropolitan Park on June 17 for a "hempfest." The group is unhappy,
however, because the city plans to charge a fee.
The group said the city waives its fee for some groups and therefore
city officials are discriminating against this group because they
don't like its pro-marijuana message.
In seeking an injunction, the group characterizes the fees as a
violation of its members' federal civil rights, including free speech.
Someone must pay expenses associated with any large gathering in a
public park, such as police protection and cleanup services. Taxpayers
absorb the costs at city-sponsored events, such as the Fourth of July
show. But sponsors of private events are billed, without exception, a
city official says.
If the event were adopted as a city-sponsored event, it could raise
constitutional questions about government giving official sanction to
one political cause over another.
The First Amendment does not guarantee "free" speech and assembly. It
guarantees "freedom of" speech and assembly. There is a major
distinction. Government must allow people to say whatever they want
about a public policy issue. But it isn't obligated to pay the cost of
spreading that message.
The cannabis group wants to solicit signatures on petitions to get a
con-stitutional amendment legalizing marijuana for medical purposes
on the 2002 statewide ballot. Only about 10 percent of the needed
signatures have been collected.
Supporters have other options if they don't want to pay fees --
telephone solicitations, direct mail and adver-tising, conducting a
door-to-door campaign or handling out fliers on the street, for example.
The "civil rights" hyperbole probably is a good campaign tactic
because it portrays marijuana advocates as underdogs in a struggle
against a big and unbending government. Legally speaking, it is merely
blowing smoke.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...