News (Media Awareness Project) - US TX: Tainted Evidence Blamed As 17 Drug Cases Dropped |
Title: | US TX: Tainted Evidence Blamed As 17 Drug Cases Dropped |
Published On: | 2001-04-05 |
Source: | Houston Chronicle (TX) |
Fetched On: | 2008-09-01 14:06:09 |
TAINTED EVIDENCE BLAMED AS 17 DRUG CASES DROPPED
DALLAS -- Prosecutors in South Central Texas have dismissed 17 drug cases
filed by a narcotics task force that was accused of targeting suspects
because of their race.
But a district attorney said Wednesday that he had recommended the
dismissals in the Hearne drug bust because of allegedly tainted evidence
provided by an informant -- not racial targeting by the South Central
Narcotics Task Force.
Dismissals of the cocaine prosecutions came a week after the American Civil
Liberties Union told the U.S. Justice Department that the task force
violated civil rights of blacks in the drug bust that led to 28 arrests.
Eleven others pleaded guilty earlier to charges from last year's bust.
Robertson County District Attorney John Paschall said the informant in the
other cases had failed a polygraph test and was suspected of tampering with
evidence.
The ACLU's Texas chapter, which had challenged a drug sting in the
Panhandle town of Tulia over alleged civil rights violations two years ago,
amended its complaint in that case to include the Hearne arrests.
But Paschall denied that the civil rights group's efforts prompted the
decision to dismiss the cases in Hearne, about 140 miles south of Dallas.
"Two weeks ahead of their alleged complaint, we had had some complaints
made by the defense attorneys" in the cases, the prosecutor said.
"We checked out the allegations. He failed the polygraph test," he added
A grand jury will meet April 10 to consider evidence involving the
informant, Derrick Megress of Hearne. No charges have been filed.
William Harrell, the Texas ACLU chapter's executive director, told The New
York Times he was pleased with the dismissals, but urged that the 11 who
already entered guilty pleas in Hearne be permitted to withdraw those pleas
and have their cases dismissed.
Twenty-seven of the Hearne defendants were black.
"We still believe that all of these people had their civil rights violated,
and that the Justice Department should proceed with its investigation and
sanction the task forces in Hearne and Tulia," said Harrell.
He did not return a telephone call Wednesday from The Associated Press.
The Justice Department is investigating the Tulia bust which brought
national attention and questions about the way the state's drug task forces
conduct investigations.
Many of the 40 cases against black Tulia residents were based solely on the
testimony of an undercover officer who was charged with theft and abuse of
power during his 18-month investigation.
Paschall said his task force's work in Hearne, 20 miles northwest of Texas
A&M University, will continue even though new charges will not be sought in
the dismissed cases.
"They will likely re-offend," he said. "We won't worry about it too much."
DALLAS -- Prosecutors in South Central Texas have dismissed 17 drug cases
filed by a narcotics task force that was accused of targeting suspects
because of their race.
But a district attorney said Wednesday that he had recommended the
dismissals in the Hearne drug bust because of allegedly tainted evidence
provided by an informant -- not racial targeting by the South Central
Narcotics Task Force.
Dismissals of the cocaine prosecutions came a week after the American Civil
Liberties Union told the U.S. Justice Department that the task force
violated civil rights of blacks in the drug bust that led to 28 arrests.
Eleven others pleaded guilty earlier to charges from last year's bust.
Robertson County District Attorney John Paschall said the informant in the
other cases had failed a polygraph test and was suspected of tampering with
evidence.
The ACLU's Texas chapter, which had challenged a drug sting in the
Panhandle town of Tulia over alleged civil rights violations two years ago,
amended its complaint in that case to include the Hearne arrests.
But Paschall denied that the civil rights group's efforts prompted the
decision to dismiss the cases in Hearne, about 140 miles south of Dallas.
"Two weeks ahead of their alleged complaint, we had had some complaints
made by the defense attorneys" in the cases, the prosecutor said.
"We checked out the allegations. He failed the polygraph test," he added
A grand jury will meet April 10 to consider evidence involving the
informant, Derrick Megress of Hearne. No charges have been filed.
William Harrell, the Texas ACLU chapter's executive director, told The New
York Times he was pleased with the dismissals, but urged that the 11 who
already entered guilty pleas in Hearne be permitted to withdraw those pleas
and have their cases dismissed.
Twenty-seven of the Hearne defendants were black.
"We still believe that all of these people had their civil rights violated,
and that the Justice Department should proceed with its investigation and
sanction the task forces in Hearne and Tulia," said Harrell.
He did not return a telephone call Wednesday from The Associated Press.
The Justice Department is investigating the Tulia bust which brought
national attention and questions about the way the state's drug task forces
conduct investigations.
Many of the 40 cases against black Tulia residents were based solely on the
testimony of an undercover officer who was charged with theft and abuse of
power during his 18-month investigation.
Paschall said his task force's work in Hearne, 20 miles northwest of Texas
A&M University, will continue even though new charges will not be sought in
the dismissed cases.
"They will likely re-offend," he said. "We won't worry about it too much."
Member Comments |
No member comments available...