News (Media Awareness Project) - US TX: Column: Thank Ex-Narc For Task Force Reform |
Title: | US TX: Column: Thank Ex-Narc For Task Force Reform |
Published On: | 2003-04-15 |
Source: | Houston Chronicle (TX) |
Fetched On: | 2008-08-26 20:33:36 |
THANK EX-NARC FOR TASK FORCE REFORM
Let's nominate Tom Coleman for some special recognition because of the huge
change in drug law enforcement that he is bringing about almost
single-handedly.
On Tuesday, the Texas House of Representatives voted to abolish all the
regional narcotics task forces in the state. Hopefully, the Senate will
follow suit and we can relegate to the history books a painful and
embarrassing chapter of our state's drug law enforcement efforts.
Let's recognize Coleman for his pivotal role in this, even though he no
longer does that kind of work and hopefully will never do it again.
He already got one award. He was named Texas Narcotics Control Program
Lawman of the Year for the work that resulted in his 1999 Tulia drug bust.
He was held up as a sterling example of the kind of officer all task force
cops should strive to be. Texas Attorney General John Cornyn, who later was
elected to the U.S. Senate, handed Coleman that award.
Too loud to be ignored But pretty soon some questions started popping up
about the 46 arrests and 38 convictions that resulted from Coleman's
award-winning bust. Questions about his background. Questions about the
testimony he gave in court. Questions that kept growing louder and louder
as they were shouted again and again from the pages of newspapers and
magazines across the country.
Questions that led to the announcement of a federal investigation and
finally even caused Cornyn to announce an attorney general's investigation
into the Tulia bust. Neither investigation has gone anywhere and both
appear intended more as political ploys rather than actual probes. Even so,
the investigation announcements point out what a major impact Coleman had.
A group of activists and volunteer lawyers who worked long and hard to set
things right eventually managed to win an evidentiary hearing into four of
the Tulia cases. The judge recommended to the Court of Criminal Appeals
that, because Coleman's testimony was so thoroughly unreliable, not just
the four cases under review, but all 38 convictions should be set aside.
That includes all the people who were coerced into taking plea bargains.
Thirteen Tulia people are still serving time on the sentences they got
because of Coleman's tainted testimony and they may not be released for
several more weeks. Our high court judges still are trying to figure out
how to undo what Coleman did without causing the entire justice system to
topple over because of it.
Unplanned benefit of scandal Will Harrell, executive director of the
American Civil Liberties Union of Texas in Austin, said Tuesday that
Coleman "has done more to foster police accountability in this state than
anyone in recent history."
Harrell called me shortly after the House voted to end the regional task
force system, made up of 43 units throughout the state. He sounded happy.
He has invested a lot of lobbying energy in this and other needed reforms
that the Tulia scandal highlights.
The Tulia bust, Harrell often points out, is but one of many shameful task
force operations conducted through the past 15 years. He has called the
narcotics task forces "a failed experiment that have filled Texas prisons
with nonviolent offenders, many of them African-American, and tainted Texas
law enforcement with scandal."
We can never expect to know how many other task force undercover cops
through the years have caused people to get convicted unjustly.
But we can try to see that Coleman gets all he deserves for conducting an
operation so outrageous it could not be ignored or swept under the rug.
Let's nominate Tom Coleman for some special recognition because of the huge
change in drug law enforcement that he is bringing about almost
single-handedly.
On Tuesday, the Texas House of Representatives voted to abolish all the
regional narcotics task forces in the state. Hopefully, the Senate will
follow suit and we can relegate to the history books a painful and
embarrassing chapter of our state's drug law enforcement efforts.
Let's recognize Coleman for his pivotal role in this, even though he no
longer does that kind of work and hopefully will never do it again.
He already got one award. He was named Texas Narcotics Control Program
Lawman of the Year for the work that resulted in his 1999 Tulia drug bust.
He was held up as a sterling example of the kind of officer all task force
cops should strive to be. Texas Attorney General John Cornyn, who later was
elected to the U.S. Senate, handed Coleman that award.
Too loud to be ignored But pretty soon some questions started popping up
about the 46 arrests and 38 convictions that resulted from Coleman's
award-winning bust. Questions about his background. Questions about the
testimony he gave in court. Questions that kept growing louder and louder
as they were shouted again and again from the pages of newspapers and
magazines across the country.
Questions that led to the announcement of a federal investigation and
finally even caused Cornyn to announce an attorney general's investigation
into the Tulia bust. Neither investigation has gone anywhere and both
appear intended more as political ploys rather than actual probes. Even so,
the investigation announcements point out what a major impact Coleman had.
A group of activists and volunteer lawyers who worked long and hard to set
things right eventually managed to win an evidentiary hearing into four of
the Tulia cases. The judge recommended to the Court of Criminal Appeals
that, because Coleman's testimony was so thoroughly unreliable, not just
the four cases under review, but all 38 convictions should be set aside.
That includes all the people who were coerced into taking plea bargains.
Thirteen Tulia people are still serving time on the sentences they got
because of Coleman's tainted testimony and they may not be released for
several more weeks. Our high court judges still are trying to figure out
how to undo what Coleman did without causing the entire justice system to
topple over because of it.
Unplanned benefit of scandal Will Harrell, executive director of the
American Civil Liberties Union of Texas in Austin, said Tuesday that
Coleman "has done more to foster police accountability in this state than
anyone in recent history."
Harrell called me shortly after the House voted to end the regional task
force system, made up of 43 units throughout the state. He sounded happy.
He has invested a lot of lobbying energy in this and other needed reforms
that the Tulia scandal highlights.
The Tulia bust, Harrell often points out, is but one of many shameful task
force operations conducted through the past 15 years. He has called the
narcotics task forces "a failed experiment that have filled Texas prisons
with nonviolent offenders, many of them African-American, and tainted Texas
law enforcement with scandal."
We can never expect to know how many other task force undercover cops
through the years have caused people to get convicted unjustly.
But we can try to see that Coleman gets all he deserves for conducting an
operation so outrageous it could not be ignored or swept under the rug.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...