News (Media Awareness Project) - US: Web: War on Drugs As a Destroyer of the Family Unit |
Title: | US: Web: War on Drugs As a Destroyer of the Family Unit |
Published On: | 2008-07-04 |
Source: | DrugSense Weekly (DSW) |
Fetched On: | 2008-07-05 22:35:16 |
WAR ON DRUGS AS A DESTROYER OF THE FAMILY UNIT
I've long talked about how the war on drugs damages the inner cities
and low income areas. The lure of black market profits is greater,
the transactions tend to be more public, and there's a stronger
direct push for arrest and incarceration.
One of the casualties of this is the family left behind when dad is
sent to prison for dealing. Now you've got a poor family in a poor
neighborhood, without a father figure, dependent on welfare, and the
kids grow up looking for an escape from that life (gangs, drugs, etc.)
And again, for any of the mindless "well, don't do the crime if you
can't do the time" law and order types, this is not just about
individual choices -- it's about the fact that prohibition creates
certain destructive economic incentives and realities. By continuing
to stand in front of a long line of about-to-be incarcerated drug
criminals individually saying "he deserves it... he deserves it... he
deserves it..." you ignore your responsibility as a rational player
in society to make societal changes for the better.
So one of the realities is the broken family. But Reason's Kerry
Howley takes it a step further in the Los Angeles Times (
http://drugsense.org/url/l6jhSHUH ), opining that more families
suffer the fallout than just those who have a male in prison:
"For low-income black women, the world really isn't cooperating. We
put an awful lot of nonviolent black men behind bars, which is not
generally conducive to good fathering. With so many young men
absent, the marriage markets are heavily skewed against women, and
mothers who might otherwise demand that men stay home and change
diapers find themselves in a miserable bargaining position. In his
book 'The Logic of Life,' Tim Harford describes one study indicating
that 'a one-percentage- point increase in the proportion of young
black men in prison reduces the proportion of young black women who
have ever been married by three percentage points.'"
Ilya Somin of Volokh Conspiracy follows up in "Why the War on Drugs
is Bad for Family Values" ( http://volokh.com/posts/1214680020.shtml ):
"Some conservatives might argue that the kinds of men who get
arrested for drug possession or dealing wouldn't make good husbands
even if they stay out of prison. Perhaps that is true in some cases.
But these men still probably beat the alternative of single
parenthood. Moreover, Kerry's point about bargaining position is
crucial here. If fewer men from these communities were in prison,
there would be more competition between them in the dating market and
thus stronger incentives for them to behave in ways that appeal to women."
These are important points to remember when discussing the war on
drugs with social conservatives in particular.
If they believe that the two-parent family is a value that should be
desired, then the drug war is a negative factor in achieving that dream.
And stop worrying about gays destroying marriage. The real danger to
marriage is prohibition.
I've long talked about how the war on drugs damages the inner cities
and low income areas. The lure of black market profits is greater,
the transactions tend to be more public, and there's a stronger
direct push for arrest and incarceration.
One of the casualties of this is the family left behind when dad is
sent to prison for dealing. Now you've got a poor family in a poor
neighborhood, without a father figure, dependent on welfare, and the
kids grow up looking for an escape from that life (gangs, drugs, etc.)
And again, for any of the mindless "well, don't do the crime if you
can't do the time" law and order types, this is not just about
individual choices -- it's about the fact that prohibition creates
certain destructive economic incentives and realities. By continuing
to stand in front of a long line of about-to-be incarcerated drug
criminals individually saying "he deserves it... he deserves it... he
deserves it..." you ignore your responsibility as a rational player
in society to make societal changes for the better.
So one of the realities is the broken family. But Reason's Kerry
Howley takes it a step further in the Los Angeles Times (
http://drugsense.org/url/l6jhSHUH ), opining that more families
suffer the fallout than just those who have a male in prison:
"For low-income black women, the world really isn't cooperating. We
put an awful lot of nonviolent black men behind bars, which is not
generally conducive to good fathering. With so many young men
absent, the marriage markets are heavily skewed against women, and
mothers who might otherwise demand that men stay home and change
diapers find themselves in a miserable bargaining position. In his
book 'The Logic of Life,' Tim Harford describes one study indicating
that 'a one-percentage- point increase in the proportion of young
black men in prison reduces the proportion of young black women who
have ever been married by three percentage points.'"
Ilya Somin of Volokh Conspiracy follows up in "Why the War on Drugs
is Bad for Family Values" ( http://volokh.com/posts/1214680020.shtml ):
"Some conservatives might argue that the kinds of men who get
arrested for drug possession or dealing wouldn't make good husbands
even if they stay out of prison. Perhaps that is true in some cases.
But these men still probably beat the alternative of single
parenthood. Moreover, Kerry's point about bargaining position is
crucial here. If fewer men from these communities were in prison,
there would be more competition between them in the dating market and
thus stronger incentives for them to behave in ways that appeal to women."
These are important points to remember when discussing the war on
drugs with social conservatives in particular.
If they believe that the two-parent family is a value that should be
desired, then the drug war is a negative factor in achieving that dream.
And stop worrying about gays destroying marriage. The real danger to
marriage is prohibition.
Member Comments |
No member comments available...